Controversy Over Citizens Police Review Board in Tallahassee

News Summary

Tallahassee’s City Commission is considering disbanding the Citizens Police Review Board after a narrow vote of 4-1. A public hearing is scheduled for January 15, 2025, to discuss the implications of repealing the board, against the backdrop of new state legislation limiting civilian oversight. Concerns about community engagement and the board’s effectiveness have emerged, reflecting the city’s desire for better police accountability amid shifting local sentiments.

Controversy Brews in Tallahassee Over Citizens Police Review Board

Tallahassee is currently navigating a stormy sea of controversy as the City Commission has voted to consider disbanding the Citizens Police Review Board (CPRB). The decision came through a narrow vote of 4-1 on December 11, 2024, leading to a scheduled public hearing on January 15, 2025, to debate the potential repeal of the ordinance that created the board.

A Divided Commission

Notably, the vote saw a supportive majority, including the Mayor and multiple commissioners, while one commissioner stood firmly against the idea. Although one commissioner, Jeremy Matlow, voted in favor of scheduling the hearing, he expressed that he is not fond of disbanding the CPRB. His desire for more public discourse on the matter indicates that the issue isn’t just black and white.

On the other hand, Commissioner Jack Porter voiced concerns about the rushed timeline for the public hearing, stating that more time is needed for a thorough examination of what the CPRB has accomplished and whether disbanding it is the right move. Her position reflects a broader unease among citizens who feel that the decision may not adequately consider the implications it holds for community oversight.

A Response to State Legislation

The commission’s deliberations are taking place against the backdrop of new legislation recently passed in Florida. This law, known as House Bill 601, aims to limit the powers of civilian oversight boards like the CPRB, prohibiting them from investigating complaints against law enforcement. Instead, these boards may only discuss policy, procedure, training, and other cultural aspects related to law enforcement. This change has paralleled similar actions in other Florida cities such as Tampa, Miami, Orlando, and Kissimmee, all of which have opted to dissolve their review boards under the new state guidelines.

A Call for Change

During discussions at the city commission level, several alternatives to the current structure of the CPRB were floated. Many city officials have expressed a desire for better community engagement concerning police matters, hinting that the current model may be outdated or ineffective under the new law. Mayor Dailey has signaled his willingness to vote in favor of the repeal of this board come January, suggesting a significant shift in oversight in the city.

Reacting to the Challenges

The challenges faced by the CPRB since its inception in 2020 have been numerous. From resignations of members to issues with maintaining a quorum for meetings, it is clear that navigating citizen oversight has not been smooth sailing for the Tallahassee community. The CPRB was originally established in the wake of civil unrest prompted by police shootings that year, with hopes of enhancing transparency and accountability in law enforcement.

Despite the board’s previously defined role to review police policies and provide recommendations—some of which found their way to the Chief of Police for consideration—it seems that local sentiments are shifting. Delilah Pierre, president of the Tallahassee Community Action Committee, has openly criticized the local officials’ push to consider the repeal, framing the narratives around police oversight and accountability as critical issues for community safety.

Looking Ahead

As the January 15 public hearing approaches, Tallahassee residents will have the chance to voice their opinions on the future of the CPRB. The significant push from local officials to dissolve the board raises important questions on how community oversight will evolve in a landscape that continues to change.

Many residents will eagerly await the hearing, hoping to share their thoughts on police accountability, community safety, and the essential role that citizen review boards can play in driving necessary change.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

HERE Resources

Tallahassee City Commission Approves Zoning Amendment and Plans Review of Citizens Police Board

Additional Resources

• Tallahassee Reports: Set to Disband Citizens Police Review Board
• Tallahassee Democrat: Law Prompts Vote to End Citizens Police Review Board in Tallahassee
• Sun Sentinel: South Florida’s Civilian Police Oversight Boards Shutter After Statewide Ban
• Tallahassee Democrat: City Commission Looks to Protect Citizen Police Review Board
• Florida Phoenix: Desantis OKs Bills Halting Police Civilian Oversight
• Wikipedia: Civilian Police Review Boards
• Google Search: Citizen Police Review Board
• Google Scholar: Citizen Oversight Board Florida
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Policing
• Google News: Police Oversight Florida