Tallahassee Debates Disbanding Citizens Police Review Board

News Summary

The Tallahassee city commission is facing backlash as it moves to disband the Citizens Police Review Board (CPRB). With a vote of 4-1, officials scheduled a public hearing for January 15, 2025, to discuss repealing the ordinance. Community leaders have expressed concerns over police accountability, leading to a heated debate on the board’s future amidst recent legislative changes in Florida.

Tallahassee Sparks Controversy Over Citizens Police Review Board

The city of Tallahassee is at the center of a heated debate as local officials have taken significant steps to disband the Citizens Police Review Board (CPRB). On December 11, 2024, the city commission, with a vote of 4-1, decided to schedule a public hearing on January 15, 2025, to discuss the potential repeal of the ordinance that created the CPRB just a few years ago.

City Commission’s Vote

This vote saw the backing of Mayor John Dailey as well as Commissioners Dianne Williams-Cox, Curtis Richardson, and Jeremy Matlow. In contrast, Commissioner Jack Porter was the sole voice against holding the hearing, expressing her concern that more investigation was needed before making such a drastic decision.

While Commissioner Matlow did support the idea of a hearing, he emphasized the need to carefully consider the arguments on both sides rather than outright shutting down the board. His approach suggests a willingness to engage in dialogue about the board’s future, an idea that may resonate with portions of the community that have rallied around the CPRB.

Community Backlash

Delilah Pierre, president of the Tallahassee Community Action Committee. Her criticism of city officials for even contemplating the board’s repeal hit a nerve, underscoring the lingering frustrations regarding police conduct in the area.

Recent Legislative Changes

The decision to review the CPRB is part of a broader trend in Florida driven by recent state legislation. Similar actions have occurred in other cities like Tampa, Miami, Orlando, Fort Myers, and Kissimmee, which have also moved to shut down their police review boards. This wave comes on the heels of the 2024 Florida legislative session, which introduced several bills aimed at reducing the power of civilian oversight boards.

One of the most notable proposals, House Bill 601, restricts the functions of these boards, allowing them to discuss police policies but prohibiting them from conducting any investigations into law enforcement misconduct after July 1, 2024. These legislative changes have raised concerns about the future of police accountability in the state and have fostered a contentious atmosphere as community members and officials navigate this complex issue.

A Brief History of the CPRB

Established on September 23, 2020, the CPRB was born out of community demands for increased oversight following a series of alarming police-related incidents in Tallahassee. However, the board has faced significant challenges, including multiple member resignations and ongoing struggles to maintain a quorum, which is critical for its functioning. These issues have led to criticism from community members regarding the board’s ability to fulfill its intended role effectively.

Looking Ahead

Mayor Dailey has indicated readiness to support the repeal at the upcoming public hearing, creating a sense of urgency among those who favor maintaining the CPRB. Meanwhile, law enforcement personnel have voiced their criticism of the board, arguing that the presence of political activists compromises trust in police services.

The ongoing debate surrounding the CPRB reflects a broader tension in Florida’s political landscape, showcasing the push and pull between community accountability and law enforcement interests. As this conversation continues to unfold, many are keenly watching the outcomes of the upcoming public hearing and the implications for police community relations in Tallahassee.